Skip to main content

Watch Us Rise by Renee Watson and Ellen Hagan

**SPOILERS BE HERE**

I didn't hate this book; it was actually quite compelling and I finished it in two days. But I hated Chelsea and most of this review will be about that. First, I'll talk about the positives. Jasmine's story was very interesting, and she was extremely likable. Her romance with Isaac was so cute. I liked the...relationship seems like too strong of a word but I'm struggling to find a better one. I liked the relationship progression between her and Meg, and how Meg seemed like she was starting to change her way of thinking. And that's about it for the good stuff.

I'm getting it out of the way—I've never enjoyed poetry and still don't, so I was pretty tempted to skim all of that. I didn't, but I caught myself trying to a few times.

The characters' actions seemed a bit extreme. Meg and her crew dressing up as princesses and racist stereotypes for Halloween to prove a point....I just couldn't see it happening in real life. Particularly the stereotype costumes, especially considering their school. The main characters actually plastering and throwing around fliers all over the school and staging a walkout and probably doing other things I've already managed to forget....I don't know. I can see how they thought that was a good idea because they felt like they weren't being heard, but they could have gone about it in better ways. Oh, accusing a teacher (not by name, but not hiding who it was) of being racist on a school blog? I'm surprised their blog wasn't taken down immediately; Jasmine had every right to tell that story, but not necessarily on school property. 

Speaking of the blog, how did that even work? From the likes and comments, it seemed like it was supposed to be on tumblr or something similar, but if they logged onto the school website to post it....color me confused. I may just not be hip with the times. And how did it become so popular? If they were making all these waves, how come no one else joined? 

And now for Chelsea. She, in particular, was a lot extreme. Passion is great. Fighting for equality and against racism and sexism is amazing. Her actions were not. She was so judgmental! Who cares if your teacher is going home to cook? Who cares if your mom is cooking? If she hasn't complained about it and doesn't mind, it's not sexist. Feminists can like wearing makeup and caring about how they look. And the "womyn" thing was so cringey. And why did she keep trying to pick fights with her mom for no reason? This book should have just been from Jasmine's POV. We didn't even get to really hear about her dad's death! It was completely swept under a rug, except for a brief mention of the funeral and her randomly crying while doing laundry one day. Really? What was the point of having him die if it wasn't going to contribute to the plot? Oh, and Chelsea not ordering Jasmine a shirt that will fit her or noticing that she's maybe uncomfortable when they go shopping and never buys clothes? Ouch.

Anyway, I'll stop my ranting. I actually did enjoy the book, but it just had too many implausibilities and kind of read like a 14-year-old's guide to feminism after watching one extreme YouTube video on the patriarchy. Which is maybe the point since they're young and impressionable and haven't really formed nuanced, educated opinions yet (Chelsea).  

Completed: 7 December 2020
Rating: 2/5 (I talked the rating down with all my ranting)
Recommend: ...honestly, I don't know. It's an easy read, just be prepared for Chelsea

10 December 2020 Update

I just remembered what really bothered me! They stage a protest while their school is getting an award for its social justice programs. Ok, I get it, you feel wronged because your club was shut down and you don't think your voices are being heard. This is not the time nor place to bring it up. The school probably does a lot more than most when it comes to social justice, and probably really deserves the award, so to completely ruin the moment is very juvenile.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Royal We by Heather Cocks and Jessica Morgan

  **SPOILERS BE HERE** I am whelmed. I'm also ignoring that this is a fictionalized account of William and Kate. The beginning of the book was great! I was super into it and it was cheesy cute, which was exactly what I needed after reading the very dry  Presidency of William Howard Taft . I love how Bex and Nick bonded over a trashy TV show and Twinkies. They were so cute together. But it went south pretty quickly after Part 1. This book was just so long . It does span eight years, but I couldn't have told you that because the time jumps were difficult to follow. Has a year passed? Have three? Who knows? What could have been the most interesting parts were completely skipped over—Bex goes home to finish university but it's only briefly mentioned. Visit the long-distance relationship and her decision to move to England! Her father dies but we barely get to see her grieving (not due to a time jump). What about her settling into a new country full time? Or her job, which is ju...
Post a Comment
Read more

Les Miserables by Victor Hugo (Translated by Norman Denny)

  **SPOILERS BE HERE** Last year, I decided to read War and Peace  and Les Miserables  in 2020. They're both around 360 chapters long, so reading two chapters a day would enable me to finish them both by the end of the year.  I succeeded!  I actually finished War and Peace  in April (cuz COVID) and then waited until July to start Les Miserables. I've also already read Les Miserables  twice before now, but this was my first time reading this translation. I prefer the Fahnestock/MacAfee/Wilbour translation; I wasn't a fan of how this one cut out two sections and added them to the end.  Oh wait! I've read an abridged version, too, one based on the 1998 film with Liam Neeson. That one is terrible; unabridged or bust! Ok so maybe not unabridged or bust. If you had asked me about 10 years ago (the last time I read it), I would have said that, but now I think some sections could be reduced or cut out. Those two that were slapped onto the end weren't very...
Post a Comment
Read more

Little Fires Everywhere by Celeste Ng

 SPOILERS BE HERE I really wanted to enjoy this book, but it fell flat for me. I 100% believe part of that was due to me listening to it rather than reading it—I drifted in and out and couldn't keep the characters straight, specifically Izzy and Lexie; something about their names is too similar. I think the plot was interesting, but actions were random and didn't make sense. Why did Mia keep Pearl? I never felt like that decision was fully explored—she just up and left. And why did Izzy (...not Lexie, right?) set fires in the house? That seemed like such an extreme response to the things that happened. The characters were not fleshed out enough. I also felt like I was being led a little too much to sympathize with certain characters and dislike others.  I said the plot was interesting; it was also clunky. It jumped around from one thing to another so sporadically that it felt like a different book at times. It could have been handled a lot more smoothly by cutting some of the ...
Post a Comment
Read more